These days, there are many options for investing money. Real estate, savings accounts, and stocks – you name it. You’ve probably heard a lot about the terms ‘index funds’, ‘mutual funds’, or ‘ETFs’, especially if you have friends who have invested in these options. In case you have been wondering what each of these is, this article will explain the simple definitions of each and cover the differences. This will help you to choose which option is right for you.


What are Mutual Funds, ETFs, and Index Funds?

The three options I have mentioned so far are financial instruments issued by investment banks. Investment banks differ from consumer banks – which typically save your money in conventional bank accounts – by dealing in investment funds instead. Investment funds are basically collections of assets in different ratios that can be traded (in the form of units) through investment accounts with cash.

Each fund offers a rate of return on your initial investment which is paid by dividends. The value of your investment may also grow if the value of the assets that make up the fund appreciates over time, and vice versa. You can redeem your funds by selling the fund units for cash.


What is an Expense Ratio?

An expense ratio of any fund is the ratio of operating expenses to its rate of return. In other words, it is the cost of owning a particular investment portfolio. It could range from something like 0.03% to as high as 2.5%. Operating expenses reduce the asset value of a fund. A low operating expense value is, therefore, more desirable.


What is a Mutual Fund?

Mutual funds are pooled investments into bonds (government or private), securities (like company stocks), and other instruments that provide financial returns. They represent a basket of a variety of assets that are actively managed by a group of investment professionals who try to buy ‘winning’ assets to improve the overall value of the fund.


Benefits of a Mutual Fund

  • Potentially Higher Returns: Because the fund is vigorously handled by professional experts, the chances of having aggressive returns are very high. Fund managers use their expertise to buy high-performing assets to put into the larger pool of investments.
  •  Personalized Service: Mutual funds have been around for a long time and active fund managers try to give customers a friendlier experience.
  •  Liquidity: Mutual funds can be easily traded for cash with the issuing banks.
  •  Diversification: Mutual funds allow investors to have a stake in a large pool of assets that would be difficult to do otherwise.


Drawbacks of a Mutual Fund

  • Higher Expense Ratio: Because Mutual funds are managed by experts, they have a higher cost to run. The expense ratio starts typically from 0.5% and can go up to 2.5%.
  •  Less Trading Options: Mutual fund unit values are updated at the end of the day. Therefore, an investor can miss out on a potentially lucrative trading opportunity.
  •  Tax Inefficiency: Mutual fund managers have to distribute capital gains taxes to shareholders. This results in higher taxes on higher returns.
  •  Higher Minimum Investment: Many mutual fund companies request a significant investment amount to start an account.


What is an Index Fund?

An index fund represents all the shares of a fixed index. An index could be a collective basket of shares of top companies such as the S&P Top 500 Index, or the Russell 2000 Index for small companies. The main function of an index fund is to replicate the performance of the specific market it represents. It is not actively, on the other hand, managed by financial managers.


Benefits of an Index Fund

  • Lower Expense Ratio: Since index funds are passively managed, they have low operating expenses. For Index funds, the expense ratio is usually lower than 0.1%.
  •  Consistent Long-term Gains: Because an index is designed to grow over time, an Index fund will replicate it and give similar returns. Index funds have the potential to outperform more aggressively positioned funds in the long run.
  •  Immediate Reinvestment: You can reinvest your gains in your account immediately to grow your investment value.
  •  Tax Efficiency: Index funds are normally subject to lower capital gains taxes.


Drawbacks of an Index Fund

  • Less Diversification: A lack of flexibility with disadvantageous calculations of stock values are inherent to indexes. Many indexes have specific features that rely on a rigid set of rules to calculate stock prices.

The rules depend on the nature of the index. Smaller indexes may not be representative of the entire industry and their performance may be influenced by higher-priced stocks. Larger indexes are influenced by companies that have larger market capitalization, and so on. This may make the stocks more volatile, based on the performance of a handful of companies.

  •  Inability to Replicate Successful Strategies: Because index funds comprise fixed baskets of assets, they cannot be compared to flexible mutual funds where fund managers can keep changing investment strategies to yield higher returns.


What is an ETF?

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are a type of index fund that track a basket of securities and are tradeable on the stock exchange. Like Index funds, they are passively managed. They require a commission fee to be paid to a stockbroker, but recently many firms have been allowing free exchange of ETFs on the market.


Benefits of an ETF

  • Lowest Expense Ratio: This can be as low as 0.03% and is usually lower than 0.1%.
  • Convenient Trading: ETFs can be traded at any time of the day allowing investors to take advantage of fluctuating market prices during a single day.
  • Several Trading Options: ETFs can be traded like regular stocks with call and put options to mitigate risks.
  • Safe Investments: ETFs have lower rates of returns and are safe for long-term investors.
  • No Minimum Investments: ETFs are one of the easiest options to invest in terms of money.
  • Tax Efficiency: ETFs are normally subject to lower capital gains taxes.
  • Specificity: Investments can be made into sector-specific funds.


Drawbacks of an ETF

  • Less Diversification: This is the same issue with Index funds.
  • Market Volatility: Higher involvement is a must for getting good returns. Because prices can be very volatile, ETF funds require some skill and awareness on part of the investor to generate returns.
  • Lower Rates of Returns: ETFs typically have lower dividend yields than other funds.



So what’s the difference? And what option is right for me?

Mutual funds are convenient for the average investor who does not know much about stocks and financial instruments. But they are expensive to own. If you have a lot of money, don’t really like the hassle of trading and want to forget about your investment for a while, mutual funds may be just right for you.

If you like to follow market trends and don’t want to pay a high cost for investing your money, I recommend investing in an index fund. You will be rewarded with higher returns if you invest smartly in an Index fund. The ability to reinvest into an index fund is also a bonus.

ETFs are a middle ground between mutual funds and index funds. They don’t cost you much and allow you to track an industry of your choice more easily. If you’re the type of investor who also likes to buy and sell frequently according to the market trends, then ETFs are the right option for you. But like all safe investments, you may have to contend with lower investment yields.


Looking for more great content about investing, personal finance, and more? Keep tuning into the Stocks4Docs Podcast.